Why do you see DAC_OVERRIDE SELinux denials?

Hello everyone!

You could have seen SELinux denials (AVC messages) in your system in the recent release of Fedora 28 and of course Fedora Rawhide. I removed lot of rules allowing DAC_OVERRIDE capability for the process domain to bring the tightened security on SELinux enabled systems. In many cases, DAC_OVERRIDE capability is not needed and there is issue with handling UNIX permissions on objects stored in the system.

But what does DAC_OVERRIDE capability means?
In capabilities(7) man page you can find explanation. “If process has DAC_OVERRIDE capability, it can bypass file read, write and execute permissions check.”

What does it mean in reality?
Process could read, write and execute files even when there are no proper flags set on the file.

And this is a solid security hole.

Dan Walsh mentioned on his blog, that there is a myth that root is all powerful. This is not completely true, because on SELinux enabled systems, even processes ran under root user must have DAC_OVERRIDE capability allowed by SELinux policy. Aaand this is the problem for many cases on Fedora system!

Lot of daemons run as root:root user and group permissions and are accessing several files/directories in the system, but these files have too tight permissions.

Let’s make an example:

Directory below is owned by mpd user.

# ll -aZ /var/run/ | grep lirc
drwxr-xr-x. 2 lirc lirc system_u:object_r:lircd_var_run_t:s0 80 Jul 3 10:18 lirc

Following process is trying to access this directory and write logs files.

# ps -efZ | grep lircd
system_u:system_r:lircd_t:s0 root 6404 1 0 10:18 ? 00:00:00 /usr/sbin/lircd --nodaemon
system_u:system_r:lircd_t:s0 root 6405 6404 0 10:18 ? 00:00:00 [uname]

As we can see the process is owned by user root and group root. Which means that kernel will look on “others” group in UNIX permissions, and there is no written access for others.

This action should be terminated by kernel because permissions are too tight, but in discretionary access control root could bypass all permissions and access the file in the system. However, this is not allowed in mandatory access control which is implemented by SELinux.

For this reason processes owned by root needs DAC_OVERRIDE capability, or changed permissions on files/directories. In most cases this is a bug in the application package.

Dan Walsh also wrote a nice blog about this issue. He’s describing same situation on dovecot example.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.